The Self-Interpreting BibleJohn Brown of Haddington

The First Epistle of Paul the Apostle to the Corinthians

1 Corinthians 14

Chapter XIV · Vol. IV, pp. 364–366

1 Prophecy is commended, 2, 3, 4 and preferred before speaking with tongues, 6 by a comparison drawn from musical instruments. 12 Both must be referred to edification, 22 as to their true and proper end. 26 The true use of each is taught, 29 and the abuse taxed. 34 Women are forbidden to speak in the church.

Notes ↓

1 Follow aftera charity, and bdesire spiritual gifts, but rather that ye may prophesy.

a Mat.22.37,38. Ro.13.8-10. Ep.5.2.

b ch.12.28,31. Ep.1.3. Nu.11.25,29. Ro.12.6. ver.3-5.

2 Forc he that speaketh in an unknown tongue, speaketh not unto men, but unto God: ford no man understandeth1 him; howbeit2 ine the spirit he speaketh mysteries.

c Ge.11.7;42.27. De.28.49. Is.36.11. Ac.2.4;10.46;19.6.

d Ac.22.9.

1 Gr. heareth.

2 Howbeit. Although.—C.

e Ps.49.3,4;78.2. Mat.13.11. Mar.4.33. ver.29.

3 But ghe that prophesieth speaketh unto men to edification, and exhortation, and comfort.

4 He that speaketh in an unknown tongue edifieth himself; but he that prophesieth edifieth the church.

5 I would that ye all spake with tongues, buth rather that ye prophesied: for greater is he that prophesieth than he that speaketh with tongues, except he interpret, that the church may receive edifying.

h ver.3,4,6,26. Nu.11.25,29.

6 Now, brethren, iif I come unto you speaking with tongues, what shall I profit you, except I shall speak to you either by revelation, or by knowledge, or by prophesying, or by doctrine?3Cited in WLC 156 · WCF 1.8

A.M. cir. 4063. A.D. cir. 59.

i ch.11.34. Ep.1.17. ver.26.

3 Revelation concerning the coming of Christ—a subject upon which the primitive church felt deep anxiety. See 2 Th.2.1.—Knowledge of 'the deep things—the mysteries of God,' and consequently, capability of answering all difficult questions, as Paul was in this epistle.—Prophesying. See ver. 3.—Doctrine. See Mar.4.2;11.18;12.38. Jn.7.16,17. Ac.2.42, &c., in all which it is applied to the system of truth taught, or some particular portion of it singled out for illustration and proof.—C.

7 And even things without life, giving sound, jwhether pipe or harp, except they give a distinction in the sounds,4 how shall it be known what is piped or harped?

8 For if the ktrumpet give an uncertain sound, who shall prepare himself to the battle?

9 So likewise ye, except ye utter by the tongue words easy5 to be understood, how shall it be known what is spoken? for ye shall lspeak into the air.Cited in WLC 156 · WCF 1.8

5 Gr. significant.

l ch.9.26.

10 There are, it may be,6 so many kinds of voices in the world, and none of them is without signification.

6 'There are as many kinds of voices in the world,' that is, as there are living creatures with will, feelings, and language, or musical instruments capable of giving forth various sounds (see ver. 5-8), 'and none of them, as it may be, without (intentional) meaning.' See ver. 11.—C.

11 Therefore if I know not the meaning of the voice, I shall be unto him that speaketh a nbarbarian; and he that speaketh shall be a barbarian unto me.Cited in WLC 156 · WCF 1.8

12 Eveno so ye, forasmuch as ye are zealous of spiritual gifts,7 seek that ye may excel to the edifying of the church.Cited in WLC 156 · WCF 1.8

o ver.7,8;ch.12.7,31.

7 Gr. of spirits.

13 Wherefore let him that speaketh in an unknown tongue, pray8 that phe may 9interpret.

* It appears from the whole scope of the passage that some had the gift of speaking in other tongues—of pronouncing words and sentences so as to convey definite ideas to those who understood the language spoken—while the speaker himself did not understand the meaning of what he said. He was an instrument miraculously employed by the Spirit of God. Paul did not set a high value on this gift by itself. Except an interpreter were present, it was useless—a mere exhibition of miraculous power without practical good farther than to call attention to the preached gospel.—P.

8 So 'pray that (during the prayer itself) he may interpret.' This sense seems to be required by the reference, in the verse following, to the unfruitfulness (so far as the understanding of the church is concerned) of praying in an unknown tongue.—C.

p ch.12.10;ver.26,27.

9 See note * in first column.

Vol. IV, p. 365

14 For qif I pray in an unknown tongue, my spirit prayeth, but my understanding is unfruitful.1Cited in WCF 21.3

A.M. cir. 4063. A.D. cir. 59.

q Lu.24.25. Ro.14.19. ch.1.10. 2 Th.2.2.

1 Unfruitful of any edification or comfort to others.—C.

15 What is it then? rI will pray2 with the spirit, and I will pray with the understanding also: I will sing with the spirit, and I will sing with the understanding also.Cited in WLC 156, 185

r Jn.4.24. Ep.5.19. Col.3.16. Ps.47.7. ver.19,26.

2 I will pray as the Spirit of God dictates, and in words the hearer may understand.—C.

16 Else, when thou shalt bless with the spirit, how shall he that occupieth the room of the unlearned say sAmen at thy giving of thanks, seeing he understandeth not what thou sayest?Cited in WSC 107 · WLC 156, 196

17 For thou verily givest thanks well, but the other is not edified.

18 I thank my God, tI speak with tongues more than ye all:

19 Yet in the church I had rather speak five words with my understanding,3 that by my voice I might teach others also, than ten thousand words in an unknown tongue.Cited in WLC 159

3 With my understanding. That is, not merely as understanding myself, but so as to be understood by others.—C.

20 Brethren, be unot children4 in understanding: howbeit in malice vbe ye children, but in understanding be men.5

A.M. cir. 4063. A.D. cir. 59.

u Ps.119.99. Ro.16.19. Ep.4.14,15. ch.2.6,13;3.1. He.5.12;6.1-3. 2 Pe.3.18.

4 Be not children, &c., who are often contented to read, learn, and repeat what they do not understand.—C.

v Ps.131.1,2. Mat.11.25;19.14;18.3. 1 Pe.2.2.

5 Gr. perfect or of a ripe age, ch.2.6. Phi.3.15. Ps.119.99.

21 In the xlaw it is written, yWith men of other tongues and other lips will I speak unto this people; and yet for all that will they not hear me, saith the Lord.

22 Wherefore tongues are for a zsign, anot to them that believe, but to them that believe not: but prophesying serveth not for them that believe not,6 but for them which believe.

* The true design of miracles is here indicated. They were intended: 1. As prodigies to excite attention, to direct men's minds to those who performed them, and then to the doctrines they taught; 2. As signs to signify that those who performed them had supernatural or divine power, and that consequently they had a divine commission. Having a divine commission the words they were commissioned to speak were necessarily of divine authority, and infallibly true. Such a mode of argument was unnecessary to believers; but it was essential to convince others.—P.

z Mar.16.17.

a Ac.2.6. 1 Ti.1.9.

6 See note * in first column.

23 If therefore the whole church be come together into one place, and all speak with tongues, and there come in those that are unlearned, or unbelievers, will they not say bthat ye are mad?

24 Butc if all prophesy, and there come in one that believeth not, or one unlearned, he is convinced of all, he is judged of all:Cited in WLC 155, 156 · WCF 1.8

Vol. IV, p. 366

25 And thus are the secrets of his heart made manifest; and so, falling down on his face, he will worship God, and report that dGod is in you of a truth.Cited in WLC 155

A.M. cir. 4003. A.D. cir. 59.

d Is.45.14. Zec.8.23.

26 How is it then, brethren? when ye come together, eevery one of you hath a psalm, hath a doctrine, hath a tongue, hath a revelation, hath an interpretation. gLet all things be done unto edifying.Cited in WCF 1.6 · HC 103

e ver.6; ch.12.8-10.

g 2 Co.12.19; 13.10. Ep.4.12,16,29. 1 Th.5.11. Ro.14.19. ch.10.20; ver.5,12,40.

27 If any man speak in an unknown tongue, let it be by two, or at the most by three, and that by course; and let one interpret.Cited in WLC 156 · WCF 1.8

28 But if there be no interpreter, let him keep silence in the church; and let him speak to himself, and to God.Cited in WLC 156 · WCF 1.8

29 Leth the prophets speak two or three, and let the other judge.7

h ver.39; ch.2.15; 12.10. 1 Th.5.19,20.

7 That is, let them speak 'by two or three' in succession at one meeting. See ver.26.—Let the other judge of the truth of what is affirmed, by comparing it with scripture, so as to guard against those false and fanatical pretensions to the gift of prophecy which the apostle foresaw and our Lord had foretold. See Mat.7.15. 1 Jn.4.1.—C.

30 If any thing be revealed to another that sitteth by, let the ifirst hold his peace.

31 Forj ye may all prophesy8 one by one, that all may learn, and all may be comforted.

j Ro.12.7. ver.29,30.

8 Ye all (not the whole church, but as many as have the gift) may prophesy.—C.

32 Andk the spirits of the prophets are subject to the prophets.9

k ver.12.29. 1 Jn.4.1. ch.12.10. 1 Th.5.20,21.

9 For the spirits (the spiritual gifts, as the word is rendered ver. 12) are subject to (the reason and will of) the prophets—as guided by a view to decency, and edification and peace. See ver.26,33,40.—C.

33 For God is not the author of confusion,1 butl of peace, as in all churches of the saints.

1 Gr. tumult or unquietness.

l ch.12.25; 11.16.

34 Letn your women keep silence in the churches: for it is not permitted unto them to speak; but they are commanded to be under obedience, as also saith the law.

35 And if they will learn any thing, olet them ask their husbands at home: for it is a shame for women to speak in the church.

o 1 Pe.3.7. See on ver.34, with ch.11.14.

36 What! pcame the word of God out from you?2 or came it unto you only?

A.M. cir. 4063. A.D. cir. 59.

p ch.4.7. Is.2.3. Ac.xi.-xviii.

2 If 'the word of the Lord came to you,' conform to the customs of the churches whence it came, ch.11.16.—C.

37 Ifq any man think himself to be a prophet, or spiritual, let him acknowledge that the things that I write unto you are the commandments of the Lord.3Cited in WSC 2

* This is an important testimony to the plenary inspiration of Paul's epistles. Paul himself had no doubt upon the subject. He was fully convinced that what he was writing was from God; and he here lays it down as a general rule that everything purporting to be divine in its origin, or binding upon the church, should be tested by his writings. Alford has rightly said that no more direct assertion of inspiration can be uttered than this.—P.

q 2 Co.10.7. 1 Jn.4.6. ch.7.25. Lu.10.16.

3 See note * in first column.

38 Butr if any man be ignorant, let him be ignorant.4

r Re.22.11. Ps.81.12. Ho.4.17. Ge.6.3. Is.6.9,10; 44.18.

4 If any man be (wilfully) ignorant, (and obstinately shut his eyes against the light), let him be ignorant (at his own peril).—C.

39 Wherefore, brethren, scovet to prophesy, and forbid not to speak with tongues.

s ch.12.31; ver.1,3,5.

40 Lett all things be done decently and in order.Cited in WCF 1.6

t ch.11.34. Col.2.5. ver.26,27,33.

Notes

Ver. 1. Let me therefore earnestly entreat and charge you to cultivate, improve, and exercise this important grace of Christian love; and in subordination to it be zealously concerned to abound in spiritual gifts, provided it be with a view to glorify God and edify your neighbour: and I recommend to you chiefly the gift of prophecy, by which, under the direction of the Holy Ghost, ye may explain and apply the oracles of God, for instructing, edifying, and confirming one another upon the principles and in the exercise of Christian love. 2. For as to the gift of speaking unknown languages, which some of you are so fond of, it is much less useful; for let a man deliver the most important and seasonable truths, under the immediate direction of the Spirit of God, in a language which his hearers understand not, they are nothing instructed or edified by all that he says. 3. But he who explains the Old Testament types or predictions, or publishes articles of gospel truth, in plain language, speaks to his audience in a manner calculated to enlighten their understanding, awaken their conscience, warm and comfort their heart, and direct and excite them to the duties of holiness. 4. He who speaks to an audience in the now disused Hebrew, or any other unknown language, or in a style above their capacity, may express what tends to his own spiritual edification; but he who explains the Scripture, and makes known the will of God relative to the salvation of men, not only profits his own soul, but becomes instrumental in the conversion of new members to the church, or in promoting the knowledge, faith, love, and holy obedience of those formerly converted. 5, 6. I could heartily wish that ye could all speak foreign languages, but much rather that ye were skilful in explaining and applying the doctrines of divine revelation; for it is of far greater use and importance plainly to explain the mysteries and predictions of God than to discourse of his most wonderful works in a language which the hearers cannot understand. 7-9. For (to illustrate the point by similitudes) as a pipe or harp cannot excite the different passions, or direct different motions in mourning or mirth, unless the sound be made distinct and answerable to them; nor can a trumpet direct the march, the charge, or retreat of soldiers in war, unless it be distinctly and answerably sounded; so, your words are all lost unless you speak in intelligible language; and ye might as well speak to the wind if your hearers do not understand you. 10. There are perhaps as many different languages in the world as there are different nations in it, and all of them useful to convey ideas to such as understand them, but to none else. 11. If I then should meet with one who talks in a language which I do not understand, and who understands nothing of mine, neither of us could instruct, or be instructed by, or even sensibly answer one another, any more than if we were wild savages of different nations; and this will be the very case with you, if you deliver divine truths to others in an unknown language. 12. Let me then beseech you who are so zealous to obtain spiritual gifts, to be less careful in speaking strange languages, and more earnest for such gifts as may increase the number and promote the knowledge, faith, and holiness of your fellow-Christians. 13. And if any be still fond of a miraculous speaking of foreign languages, let him supplicate God for ability to interpret what he says to his hearers in their mother tongue, that they may be profited by the discourse. 14. For if I or any other should pray as the mouth of a company who understand not my words, my own heart might be engaged in the prayer, but the impression of what I say on my own mind could be of no use to them who know not the meaning of my words. 15. It is therefore manifestly proper that in leading the prayers and praises of a congregation, not only I myself should understand and be affected with what I utter, but that my language should be plain to all who profess to join with me, that they may with understanding heartily join in the work. 16. Or else if any of you, under the immediate direction of the Holy Ghost, offer thanksgiving and praises to God in a public assembly in an unknown language, he who understands nothing but his mother tongue, and comes to learn by your administrations, can never give his assent or consent, either in heart or voice, because he knows not the meaning of your words. 17. You may have performed this part of worship in a very judicious, spiritual, heavenly, and affectionate manner; but the hearers, who do not understand what you say, cannot be profited by it. 18, 19. For my part, I thank God that, in the extensive course of my ministry, I have been enabled to speak, as occasions required, in many more foreign languages than any, if not all of your teachers. But instead of priding myself in this talent, I had rather utter a few plain words, calculated for the instruction and edification of my hearers, than make ten thousand discourses in a language which they do not understand, and so cannot be profited by them. 20. Never, my brethren, show yourselves weak and childish in affecting novelties or pompous appearances; as, for instance, the speaking of unknown languages. Be like children in the meekness, harmlessness, and humility of your disposition and behaviour, and in freedom from all malicious, proud, and envious designs; but in knowledge, judgment, and discretion, especially in your apprehensions and management of spiritual things, it becomes you to think and act like men grown up to ripeness of understanding. 21, 22. To make you less fond of speaking in unknown languages, and that you may use them only in a proper manner, remember that God threatened to punish his incorrigible people by nations whose language they understood not, as well as to enable his ministers to speak in divers languages, without any happy effects. —The being spoken to in unknown languages is therefore but an occasional mean of punishing obstinate unbelievers, or a miraculous mean of converting heathens to Christ at first, by manifesting the power of God; whereas the explaining and applying the doctrines of the Old Testament is, by the ordination and blessing of God, a standing mean of gaining sinners to Jesus Christ, and of building up saints in holiness and comfort through faith unto complete salvation. 23. If then, while ye or other churches are met for worshipping God in your public assemblies, and every one that speaks, in preaching, prayer, or praise, is using an uninterpreted language which the audience does not understand, some heathen, who knows not a word of what is said, should come in, would your use of unknown languages be a likely mean of convincing or converting him; or would he not rather contemn you, as a number of frantic enthusiasts, or men possessed by the devil, rather than conducted and influenced by the infinitely wise Spirit of God? 24, 25. But if, where every minister preaches or prays plainly in a well-known language, a heathen or ignorant person come in, he has, in every discourse, a fair opportunity to be, by the Spirit of God, effectually convinced of his sin and misery, and made to condemn himself as guilty. Thus his state and secret dispositions, thoughts, and actions, being exactly laid open to his conscience by the preachers, struck with a reverential awe of God's majesty, he will be constrained, with brokenness of heart, to a deep humiliation for sin and supplication for mercy, and will report to his friends that God attends his ordinances among you with extraordinary power and influence. 26. How absurd is it, brethren, that in your meetings for public worship one of your public teachers should raise a psalm, another tender an instruction or exhortation, another speak in an unknown language, another deliver some immediate inspiration, another interpret what is delivered in an unknown tongue— perhaps all at once, or as if each were fond first to display his talents! Let these gifts of the Spirit, and everything else, be used in such an orderly and seasonable manner as to prevent all confusion, and as may be most effectual for enlarging the church of Christ, and promoting the spiritual growth of every member of it. 27. And if, after all that I have said, some of you will use foreign languages, let it be at suitable times, and in a regular manner, so that there may not ordinarily be above two or three speakers at a time, and they one after another; and let one faithfully interpret what they have said in the vulgar tongue, that all may receive instruction. 28. And if no one present can interpret it, let none use his gift of tongues, as the assembly cannot be profited by it; and let him be contented to use it in his own secret devotions. —29. And with respect to the gift of prophecy, let but two or three of them who have it speak at one of your public meetings, and that in an orderly manner, without interrupting or interfering with one another; and as many false prophets are gone abroad in the church, let everything uttered by one prophet be carefully examined and tried whether it agree with the tenor of Old Testament predictions and New Testament revelations. 30. And if any important intimation of God's mind be made to another prophet who is in the assembly as a hearer and judge, let the speaker, upon a proper signal given, stop, and give him an opportunity to declare it. 31. In this orderly manner all your teachers may have successive opportunities to declare the truths of Christ, for the instruction and comfort of one another and of the whole church. 32. And it is certain that no inspiration of the Holy Ghost can render men frantic or disorderly, as diabolic influences render the heathen priests; but it leaves every one to govern himself becomingly, either as to the matter, manner, or time of his discourse. 33. For that infinitely wise God who inspires them can never be an author, abettor, or encourager of any disorderly, unseasonable, and tumultuous conduct in his worship; but, as the God of peace and order in all the assemblies of sanctified believers, he is the commander, approver, promoter, and author of everything regular, pacific, and edifying. 34. And as for your women, let them never, except in extraordinary cases of inspiration, -speak at all in your public assemblies, but learn, according to the law of God, to discover the utmost humility and modest subjection to the other sex. 35. And if they want more thorough information about anything said in public, let them ask their husbands at home concerning it; for it is unbecoming the modesty of women, except when inspired, to presume to discourse or debate in public religious assemblies. 36. Why should ye indulge practices different from those of all other Christian churches? Ye cannot pretend that ye are the only or even the first planted church from which the truths of the gospel, and an original pattern of conduct, were conveyed to others. Are ye not then equally tied down to the institutions of Christ, the common King and Head both of you and them? 37. If any of your high pretenders to an uncommon share of spiritual gifts think himself authorized to give laws to your church, let him know that the directions which I have given you were communicated to me by the Spirit of Christ, and are founded in the general rules which he laid down in his personal ministry. 38. And if any one will perversely persist in his ignorance, contempt of, or opposition to these rules, let him do it at his peril before God, whose mind I have declared. 39. On the whole, I advise you to be most desirous of the gift of prophecy, which is most useful for general edification; and, nevertheless, I do not forbid nor discourage the regular use of the gift of tongues. 40. But in everything carefully avoid all appearance of childishness, frenzy, or other indecency, in the public worship of God, and labour to perform it in a manner exactly answerable to the commands now given you from Christ, which will most glorify God, honour his doctrines, ordinances, and ways, and edify the souls of his people.

Ver. 34. This prohibition seems to contradict ch. 11. 5, 13, where the prophesying of women appears to be taken for granted. The simplest solution of the difficulty seems to be—that the speaking here prohibited is not praying or prophesying, but asking questions and entering into discussions in the church (see ver. 35)—a custom that prevailed in the Jewish synagogues between the rabbis and the people; which had been thence transfused into the Christian church, and which, under the proper management of humility and love, seems still well calculated for the public edification. C.

Reflections.—What diversified gifts God bestowed upon his Christian church in her infant state! And those gifts which are most useful and edifying ought to be chiefly prized and sought after. What is most showy is ordinarily least useful. And every gift ought to be improved for the good purposes for which God bestows it upon men. It is absurd to preach or pray in a language which the assembly do not generally understand; and both absurd and criminal to preach in an uncertain general manner that can neither distinctly inform the mind nor closely impress the conscience. Those discourses are best which are calculated to penetrate into the hearts and consciences of hearers, the most ignorant not excepted.—The envy, malice, and self-conceit of members, especially of preachers, are highly injurious to any church. But it is very becoming and happy when all are humbly inclined to learn, careful to keep their own station, and zealous in their exact adherence to all the ordinances of God, without any mixture of human inventions.

Scan of the printed page