The Self-Interpreting BibleJohn Brown of Haddington

The General Epistle of James

James 3

Chapter III · Vol. IV, pp. 483–484

1 We are not rashly or arrogantly to reprove others: 5 but rather to bridle the tongue, a little member, but a powerful instrument of much good, and great harm. 13 They who be truly wise be mild, and peaceable, without envying, and strife.

Notes ↓

1 My brethren, abe not many masters, knowing that we shall receive the greater condemnation.1

2 Forb in many things we offend2 all.3 If cany man offend not in word, the same is a perfect man, and able also to bridle the whole body.Cited in WLC 149 · WCF 6.5

b 1 Ki.8.46. Pr.20.9. Ec.7.20. 1 Jn.1.8. Is.64.6.

2 Offend. Rather, 'fail,' 'stumble.'—C.

3 More literally, 'For oftentimes we all offend' in one form or another; in word, or thought, or action.—P.

c Ps.34.13; 39.1,2. ch.1.26. Pr.13.3; 15.1; 25.8. Mat.12.36,37. 1 Pe.3.10.

3 Behold, dwe put bits in the horses' mouths, that they may obey us; and we turn about their whole body.

4 Behold also the ships, which though they be so great, and eare driven of fierce winds, yet are they turned about with a very small helm, whithersoever the governor listeth.

5 Eveng so the tongue4 is a little member, and boasteth great things. Behold how great a matter5 a little fire kindleth!

g Ps.10.3; 12.3,4; 73.8,9. Job 21.14,15. Pr.12.18; 15.1,2. Re.13.5,6.

4 The tongue. That is, the tongue of the natural, unrenewed man.—C.

5 Or, wood.

Vol. IV, p. 484

6 Andh the tongue is a fire, a world of iniquity: so is the tongue among our members, that it defileth the whole body, and setteth on fire the course of nature; and it is set on fire of hell.

A.M. cir. 4064. A.D. cir. 60.

h ch.1.26. Pr.16.27; 15.1; 17.4. Ro.3.13,14. Ps.5.9; 64.3; 140.3. Mat.15.11-20. Mar.7.15,20-23. ver.2. Ec.7.6.

7 For every kind6 of beasts, and of birds, and of serpents, and of things in the sea, is tamed, and hath been tamed of mankind:7

6 Gr. nature.

7 Gr. the nature of man.

8 But the tongue can no man tame;8 it iis an unruly evil, full of deadly poison.

8 The tongue cannot be 'tamed;' but as an agent of 'the body,' must be 'mortified,' Ro. viii.—C.

i See ver.6. Ps.55.21; 57.4; 59.7; 58.4; 64.3,4; 140.3,4. Ro.3.13,14. Ec.10.11.

9 Therewithj bless we God,9 even the Father; and therewith curse we men,1 whichk are made after the similitude of God.

j Ps.145.21. Is.29.13.

9 i.e. when renewed by his Spirit.—C.

1 i.e. when unrenewed by God's Spirit, & led by our own.—C.

k Ge.1.27; 9.6. 1 Co.11.7.

10 Outl of the same mouth proceedeth blessing and cursing. My brethren, these things ought not so to be.

11 Doth a fountain send forth at the same place2 sweet water and bitter?

2 Or, hole.

12 Cann the fig-tree, my brethren, bear olive berries? either a vine, figs? so can no fountain both yield salt water and fresh.

13 Whoo is a wise man and endued with knowledge among you? let him show out of a good conversation his works with meekness of wisdom.

14 But if ye have pbitter envying and strife in your hearts, qglory not, and lie not against the truth.Cited in WSC 81 · WLC 148

A.M. cir. 4064. A.D. cir. 60.

p Ro.13.13. 2 Co.12.20. Ga.5.15,20,21,26.

q Ro.2.17-23. 2 Ti.3.5. Je.7.4,9. ch.1.21. 1 Pe.2.1,2.

15 Thisr wisdom descendeth not from above, but is earthly, sensual,3 devilish.Cited in WSC 81

16 Fors where envying and strife is, there is confusion4 and every evil work.Cited in WSC 81 · WLC 148

s Ga.5.15,20,21,26. 1 Co.3.3. ch.4.1.

4 Gr. tumult or unquietness.

17 Butt the wisdom that is from above is first pure,5 then peaceable, gentle, and easy to be entreated, full of mercy and good fruits, without partiality,6 and without hypocrisy.Cited in WLC 135

* This verse is often misinterpreted. It is thought to signify that in the church, in society, in doctrine, there must be purity before there can be peace—before peace is allowable. The Greek has no such meaning. Paul gives the characteristics of those who are divinely wise in order—purity, peace, &c. Peace is as essential as purity, and compassion as essential as either.—P.

t 1 Co.2.6,7. ch.1.5,17. Mat.5.7,8. Phi.4.8. Lu.6.36. 1 Ti.1.5. Ro.12.9. 2 Co.6.6. Ga.5.22; 6.9. He.12.4. 1 Th.4.3,4,9. ch.1.19,21,26,27. 1 Pe.1.22; 2.1. ch.2.1-4.

5 See note * in first column.

6 Or, wrangling.

18 Andu the fruit of righteousness7 is sown in peace of them that make peace.

u Pr.11.18. Is.32.17. Ho.10.12. 2 Co.9.10. Mat.5.9. Phi.1.11. He.12.11.

7 For the meaning of gospel 'righteousness,' see note on Ro.4.11; and for 'the fruit of righteousness,' see Ro.5.1,2.—C.

Notes

Ver. 1. Take heed, my dear Christian brethren, that none of you affect to be teachers of others, without proper qualifications for it; or give way, like your Jewish doctors, to a magisterial and censorious temper in matters of religion; for if ye do, your sin will be very aggravated, and your condemnation at the last day inexpressibly dreadful. 2. For all, even the best of us, are guilty of manifold transgressions of both tables of God's law, offending him and our fellow-creatures, which should make us very humble and modest in our thoughts of ourselves or censures of others; but if any one be enabled by grace to restrain his tongue from idle, opprobrious, false, and other sinful language, it marks him a true believer, and a person of great attainments in knowledge and experience, integrity and holiness, capable of managing himself and his whole behaviour to the benefit of the society he is connected with, religious or civil. 3-6. For as horses are governed by small bits, and large ships by small rudders, so a man's tongue, when properly managed, under the influence of divine grace, is of great use for regulating his whole behaviour—even as, under the influence of a carnal heart, it extravagantly talks away and contemns others; and I entreat you carefully to observe how often a little injurious language kindles a flame of contention and confusion all around it. And indeed scarcely anything can be more mischievous or productive of wickedness than an unruly, furious tongue. It vents a great deal of sin, is the outlet of the whole source of wickedness which lies in a man's heart, and produces much iniquity among others; by its exorbitant licentiousness, it spreads guilt and defilement through the whole man; and as a fire kindled and blown up by the diabolical influence of the father of lies and accuser of the brethren, it raises such wrath and anger in our own and other people's passions, as throws the whole course of the moral world into a pernicious ferment, and continues from one period of life, and even one generation, to another. 7, 8. No savage, venomous, or voracious beast is so hard to be tamed as a lying, reviling, malignant tongue, actuated by strong, furious, and vile passions. In the most ungovernable manner it vents forth the most devilish and destructive pride, malice, envy, reproach, and falsehood. 9-12. And very often among professed Christians it is at one time honourably employed in praising God the Father of mercies, and of Christ, and of us in him, or in praying to or commending him; and at another time basely prostituted to pour forth revilings, or even horrid imprecations, against our fellow-creatures, for whom we ought to have a reverence, as they were originally created after the image of God, in knowledge, righteousness, and holiness, and are still formed in some likeness to him in the natural faculties of their soul; and many of them, by his grace, renewed after his image in regeneration.—Nothing can be more contrary to our Christian obligations, profession, and character, or even more unnatural and absurd in itself. 13. If any of you therefore would approve yourselves to God, and show yourselves to the world as truly wise and prudent, and endowed with a true knowledge of yourselves, of Christ, and of God, his laws and ways, let them earnestly practise all manner of good works in the whole course of their conversation, with a meek and humble spirit. 14. But never be fond or boast of envious, quarrelsome, and contentious dispositions and designs, which will torment your souls, and sting and wound others, and are directly contrary to the meek and humble spirit of the gospel. Never dare, either in thought, word, or deed, to varnish over such wickedness, or to pretend to sincerity and prudence in indulging it; 15, 16. For, think as you will, this wisdom springs not from, nay, is detested by God, and arises from an excessively earthly and sensual inclination to worldly enjoyments, and is excited by the devil, bears his image, delights his heart, and promotes his mischievous designs and interests; for whenever an envious, censorious, and litigious spirit is indulged, and breaks forth in words, it tends to disturb and destroy the peace and happiness of a man's own soul, and of all about him, and leads to everything wicked. 17. But that heavenly and divine wisdom which God bestows leads men to a strict regard to purity of doctrine and manners, in heart, speech, and behaviour; it disposes to peacefulness, mildness, and courteousness in our treatment of others; it renders our mind open to conviction, easily persuaded to that which is good, and attentive to all considerations, forward to condescension and forbearance, and inclined to acts of kindness and compassion to the poor and afflicted; it renders us impartial and generous in judging and condemning of others; and sincere, free from any allowed dissimulation. 18. And this righteous, holy, and peaceable temper and conversation, by the grace of God, issues in our own and our neighbour's happiness in this world, and in our everlasting happiness and peace hereafter.

Ver. 2. Perfect, in its absolute sense, is applicable to God alone; in its comparative sense, it is the highest endowment of man, the chiefest grace of the Spirit. See it prophetically described as a special mark of the Messiah, Is. 42. 19.

Ver. 6. The course of nature. The whole circle of human life from boyhood to old age, which, unless delivered from the power of Satan, and kept by the power of God, is continually excited by surmises, misrepresentations, falsehoods, and calumnies, whereby the fires of jealousy, envy, wrath, and malice, are continually fed, and frequently blown into a fierce and devouring flame. C.

Reflections.—An assuming, arrogant, and censorious temper fearfully presages our future condemnation to hell. And the deeper sense we have of our own sinfulness and weakness, the less rash shall we be in condemning others.—It is very honourable and advantageous for Christians to have grace to govern their tongue. But how hard to rule it! and yet, if ungoverned, it kindles and spreads infinite and eternal mischiefs all around. Scarcely can anything be more inconsistent with the character of a Christian, more dishonourable to God, or more ruinous to men, than an unbridled tongue, and an envious malicious heart.—But great is the excellency of true and spiritual wisdom, in its origin, nature, properties, and fruits.

Scan of the printed page